Did early Renaissance painters trace optical projections? Evidence pro and con

David G. Stork

doi:10.1117/12.593988

17 January 2005 Did early Renaissance painters trace optical projections? Evidence pro and con

David G. Stork

Proceedings Volume 5675, Vision Geometry XIII; (2005) https://doi.org/10.1117/12.593988
Event: Electronic Imaging 2005, 2005, San Jose, California, United States

Abstract

Recently it has been theorized that some European painters as early as 1420 used concave mirrors (and, later, converging lenses) to project real inverted images onto their supports which they then traced and painted over. We review the image analytic, historical and art historical evidence and counter-evidence for this bold claim, focusing on key paintings in the debate. While some of the evidence is consistent with the use of optical projections in the 15th century, all such evidence is also consistent with other explanations as well. More importantly, for those paintings highlighted as supporting the projection theory, there is much evidence that is inconsistent with the use of optics or extremely difficult to explain as arising from the use of optics. Further, there is no historical documentary evidence from the 15th century suggesting anyone had even seen an image of an illuminated object projected onto a screen -- the first step in the proposed projection method. The projection method would have been the most sophisticated optical procedure of its day, which theory proponents speculate was discovered by artists, not the scientists who were actively exploring optical systems. Because the burden of proof lies foursquare upon the theory’s proponents -- the revisionists -- in the absence of compelling reasons to reject “traditional” (non-optical) explanations we must reject the projection theory. We conclude by rejecting the claims that the optical projection theory has been “proven.”

Citation Download Citation

David G. Stork "Did early Renaissance painters trace optical projections? Evidence pro and con", Proc. SPIE 5675, Vision Geometry XIII, (17 January 2005); https://doi.org/10.1117/12.593988

ACCESS THE FULL ARTICLE

INSTITUTIONAL
Select your institution to access the SPIE Digital Library.

SELECT YOUR INSTITUTION

PERSONAL
Sign in with your SPIE account to access your personal subscriptions or to use specific features such as save to my library, sign up for alerts, save searches, etc.

PERSONAL SIGN IN

No SPIE Account? Create one

PURCHASE THIS CONTENT

SUBSCRIBE TO DIGITAL LIBRARY

50 downloads per 1-year subscription

Members: $195

Non-members: $335 ADD TO CART

25 downloads per 1 - year subscription

Members: $145

Non-members: $250 ADD TO CART

PURCHASE SINGLE ARTICLE

Includes PDF, HTML & Video, when available