The recently introduced Photon Counting CT (PCCT) offers major advances in spatial resolution and material discrimination compared to conventional multi-detector CT. We investigate whether these new capabilities may enable accurate in vivo quantification of the trabecular microstructure of human bone. Human femoral bone was imaged using reference HR-pQCT (isotropic 60 μm voxels) and PCCT operated in a High Resolution mode (HR, 80 μm in-plane voxel size. 200 μm slice thickness) and in a Calcium-selective mode (CA, isotropic 390 μm voxels). 468 spherical Regions-of-Interest (ROIs) of 5 mm diameter were placed at corresponding locations in the HR-pQCT and PCCT volumes. The bone voxels of HR-pQCT and CA PCCT ROIs were segmented (binarized) using global Otsu thresholding; local Bernsen segmentation was used for HR PCCT. Trabecular thickness (TbTh), spacing (TbSp), number (TbN), and bone volume fraction (BV/TV) were measured in the binarized ROIs. The performance of PCCT morphometrics was evaluated in terms of correlation coefficient and numerical agreement with HR-pQCT. For ROIs with mean TbTh⪆250 μm (approaching the nominal resolution of HR PCCT), the average trabecular measurements obtained from HR PCCT achieved excellent correlations with the reference HR-pQCT: 0.88 for BvTv, 0.89 for TbTh, 0.81 for TbSp and 0.78 for TbN. For ROIs with mean TbTh of 200 μm – 250 μm, the correlations were slightly worse, ranging from 0.61 for TbTh to 0.84 for BvTv. The spatial resolution of CA PCCT in its current implementation is insufficient for microarchitectural measurements, but the material discrimination capability appears to enable accurate estimation of BvTv (correlation of 0.89 to HR-pQCT). The results suggest that the introduction of PCCT may enable microstructural evaluation of the trabecular bone of the lumbar spine and hip, which are inaccessible to current in vivo high-resolution bone imaging technologies. The findings of this work will inform the development of clinical indications for PCCT trabecular bone assessment.
The measurements of bone macro- and microstructures provide major insight into bone health and risk fracture. The accuracy of these measurements is limited when Conventional CT is used. However, CT technology has advanced with the introduction of photon-counting detectors that offer significant improvements in spatial resolution. This advancement offers potential improvements in resolving trabecular microstructures, and the quantification of bone through current or emerging biomarkers. Additionally, the spectral separation available in photon-counting CT (PCCT) may further aid in quantification. The purpose of this study was to objectively investigate PCCT capabilities in accurate quantification of bone macro- and micro-structures. To do so, 5 human bone specimens were scanned using a PCCT scanner (NAEOTOM Alpha, Siemens) and an energy-integrating CT (EICT) (FORCE, Siemens). Each specimen was imaged at a CTDIvol of 4 and 8mGy, and then reconstructed with 2 matrix sizes and at least 2 kernels. For PCCT, a 70keV virtual mono-energetic image series was acquired to evaluate the potential benefits of spectral maps. The same specimens were also scanned using a high-resolution peripheral quantitative CT to provide a ground truth for the bone metrics. Each image series was analyzed in terms of bone mineral density (BMD) and trabecular bone volume to total bone volume. PCCT demonstrated major improvements (5.5% compared to 17% error for EICT) in quantifying bone microstructures (BV/TV). However, the BMD measurements remained similar across imaging conditions and scanners, and did not significantly change by the PCCT spatial resolution enhancement. For BV/TV measurements, PCCT T3D was the most accurate when the sharpest kernel available and 1024-matrix size for (error: 5.53%±4.72%) were used. Similarly, EICT images were the most accurate for BV/TV measurements (error: 16.70%±10.55%) when a medium-sharpness kernel and 1024-matrix size were used. The overall results suggest that PCCT technology can further improve trabecular bone measurements and thus enhance the clinical decision making for patients with bone disease.
Virtual imaging trials of malignancies require realistic models of lesions. The purpose of this study was to create hybrid lesion models and associated tool incorporating morphological and textural realism. The developed tool creates a lesion morphology based on input parameters describing its shape and spiculation. Internal heterogeneity is added as 3D clustered lumpy background (CLB), allowing for various sub-classes of lesions including full solid, semi-solid, and ground-glass lesions. To insert a lesion into a full body human model (e.g., XCAT phantom), the edges of the lesion are blended into the surrounding background using a parameterizable Gaussian blurring technique. The developed lesion tool allows users to define lesion sizes either manually or automatically following population distribution of lesion sizes. Similarly, the tool allows users to insert lesions either manually or automatically while avoiding intersections with pulmonary structures. The utility of the developed lesion tool was demonstrated by modeling both homogeneous and heterogeneous lung lesions and inserting them into 5 human models (XCAT). The human models were imaged using a validated CT simulator (DukeSim). Images of heterogeneous lesions were visually comparable to clinical images. The first order and texture radiomics features (58 features) were extracted from all image series and compared using the Pearson correlation. The two lesion generation techniques for full solid lesions (homogeneous vs. heterogeneous) were observed to have a weak correlation (r<0.4) for 35 of 58 features using a soft kernel, and for 43 of 58 features using a sharp kernel—capturing the structural differences between the two models. The lesion tool proved capable of forming different lung lesion sub-classes (full-solid, semi-solid, and ground-glass) through its input parameters to emulate the lesion characteristics of interest for a virtual lesion study.
KEYWORDS: Lung, Data modeling, Computed tomography, Scanners, 3D modeling, Computer simulations, Modulation transfer functions, Chest imaging, Medicine, Medical research
Virtual Imaging Trials, known as VITs, provide a computational substitute for clinical trials. These traditional trials tend to be sluggish, costly, and frequently deficient in definitive evidence, all the while subjecting participants to ionizing radiation. Our VIT platform meticulously mimics essential components of the imaging process, encompassing everything from virtual patients and scanners to simulated readers. Within the scope of this intended research, we aim to authenticate our virtual imaging trial platform by duplicating the results of the National Lung Screening Trial (NLST) for lung cancer screening through the emulation of low-dose computed tomography (CT) and chest radiography (CXR) procedures. The methodology involves creating 66 unique computational phantoms, each with inserted simulated lung nodules. Replicating NLST CT imaging via Duke Legacy W20 scanner matched essential properties. Virtual imaging was done through DukeSim. A LUNA16-trained virtual reader, combining a 3D RetinaNet model (front-end) with a ResNet-10 false positive reduction model (back-end), evaluated the virtually imaged data, ensuring rigorous assessment. The back-end model achieved a sensitivity of over 95% at fewer than 3 false positives per scan for both the clinical and virtual imaged CTs. Notably, nodule diameter-based analysis showcases even higher sensitivity for nodules measuring 10 mm or more. In conclusion, the integration of diverse computational and imaging techniques, culminating in a virtual reader, demonstrates promising sensitivity. To capture both arms of the trial, future research will compare virtual reader performance on CT with CXR. This affirms the transformative potential of virtual imaging trials in advancing evidence-based medicine, offering an efficient and ethically conscious approach to medical research and development.
The rendition of medical images influences the accuracy and precision of quantifications. Image variations or biases make measuring imaging biomarkers challenging. The objective of this paper is to reduce the variability of computed tomography (CT) quantifications for radiomics and biomarkers using physics-based deep neural networks (DNNs). The proposed framework used the knowledge of ground truth through a virtual imaging trial (VIT) methodology to harmonize the different renditions of CT scans across variations in reconstruction kernel and dose. This harmonization was done by developing a generative adversarial network (GAN) model, informed by pixel values and patient-based modulation transfer function (MTF) estimates. To train the network, the VIT platform was used to acquire CT images from a set of forty computational human models (XCAT). Models included varying levels of pulmonary diseases including lung nodules and emphysema. The patient models were imaged with a validated CT simulator (DukeSim) modeling a commercial CT scanner operating across a range of dose (20-100 mAs) and reconstruction kernels (15 from smooth to sharp). The harmonized virtual images were evaluated in three different ways: 1) visual assessment of the images, 2) bias and variation in density-based biomarkers, and 3) bias and variation in morphological-based biomarkers. The harmonization improved the bias and variability of the test set images yielding a structural similarity index of 95±1%, a normalized mean squared error of 10.2±1.5%, and a peak signal-to-noise ratio of 31.8±1.5 dB compared to variations in these metrics when no harmonization was applied (87±9%, 14.2±4%, and 29.6±2, respectively). Emphysema-based imaging biomarkers of LAA-950 (-1.5±1.8%), Perc15 (13.65±9.3 HU), and Lung mass (0.1±0.3 g) had more precise and consistent quantifications compared to values when images were not harmonized (9.9±12%, -36.0±53 HU, and 0.2±0.4g, respectively). These results suggest that the method can be promising to improve consistency in multi-center studies when reliable and consistent quantification of data from multiple systems are required.
Photon-counting CT (PCCT) is an emerging imaging technology with potential improvements in quantification and rendition of micro-structures due to its smaller detector sizes. The aim of this study was to assess the performance of a new PCCT scanner (NAEOTOM Alpha, Siemens) in quantifying clinically relevant bone imaging biomarkers for characterization of common bone diseases. We evaluated the ability of PCCT in quantifying microarchitecture in bones compared to conventional energy-integrating CT. The quantifications were done through virtual imaging trials, using a 50 percentile BMI male virtual patient, with a detailed model of trabecular bone with varied bone densities in the lumbar spine. The virtual patient was imaged using a validated CT simulator (DukeSim) at CTDIvol of 20 and 40 mGy for three scan modes: ultra-high-resolution PCCT (UHR-PCCT), high-resolution PCCT (HR-PCCT), and a conventional energy-integrating CT (EICT) (FORCE, Siemens). Further, each scan mode was reconstructed with varying parameters to evaluate their effect on quantification. Bone mineral density (BMD), trabecular volume to total bone volume (BV/TV), and radiomics texture features were calculated in each vertebra. The most accurate BMD measurements relative to the ground truth were UHR-PCCT images (error: 3.3% ± 1.5%), compared to HR-PCCT (error: 5.3% ± 2.0%) and EICT (error: 7.1% ± 2.0%). UHR-PCCT images outperformed EICT and HR-PCCT. In BV/TV quantifications, UHR-PCCT (errors of 29.7% ± 11.8%) outperformed HR-PCCT (error: 80.6% ± 31.4%) and EICT (error: 67.3% ± 64.3). UHR-PCCT and HR-PCCT texture features were sensitive to anatomical changes using the sharpest kernel. Conversely, the texture radiomics showed no clear trend to reflect the progression of the disease in EICT. This study demonstrated the potential utility of PCCT technology in improved performance of bone quantifications leading to more accurate characterization of bone diseases.
KEYWORDS: Monte Carlo methods, Sensors, Imaging systems, Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, Computed tomography, Scanners, Lung, Systems modeling, Signal detection, Modulation transfer functions
The purpose of this study was to develop a virtual imaging framework that simulates a new photon-counting CT (PCCT) system (NAEOTOM Alpha, Siemens). The PCCT simulator was built upon the DukeSim platform, which generates projection images of computational phantoms given the geometry and physics of the scanner and imaging parameters. DukeSim was adapted to account for the geometry of the PCCT prototype. To model the photon-counting detection process, we utilized a Monte Carlo-based detector model with the known properties of the detectors. We validated the simulation platform against experimental measurements. The images were acquired at four dose levels (CTDIvol of 1.5, 3.0, 6.0, and 12.0 mGy) and reconstructed with three kernels (Br36, Br40, Br48). The experimental acquisitions were replicated using our developed simulation platform. The real and simulated images were quantitatively compared in terms of image quality metrics (HU values, noise magnitude, noise power spectrum, and modulation transfer function). The clinical utility of our framework was demonstrated by conducting two clinical applications (COPD quantifications and lung nodule radiomics). The phantoms with relevant pathologies were imaged with DukeSim modeling the PCCT systems. Different imaging parameters (e.g., dose, reconstruction techniques, pixel size, and slice thickness) were altered to investigate their effects on task-based quantifications. We successfully implemented the acquisition and physics attributes of the PCCT prototype into the DukeSim platform. The discrepancy between the real and simulated data was on average about 2 HU in terms of noise magnitude, 0.002 mm-1 in terms of noise power spectrum peak frequency and 0.005 mm-1 in terms of the frequency at 50% MTF. Analysis suggested that lung lesion radiomics to be more accurate with reduced pixel size and slice thickness. For COPD quantifications, higher doses, thinner slices, and softer kernels yielded more accurate quantification of density-based biomarkers. Our developed virtual imaging platform enables systematic comparison of new PCCT technologies as well as optimization of the imaging parameters for specific clinical tasks.
The aim of this study was to evaluate and optimize the imaging parameters of a new dual-source photon-counting CT (PCCT) scanner (NAEOTOM Alpha, Siemens Healthineers) for lung lesion radiomics using virtual imaging trials. Virtual patients (XCAT phantoms) were modeled at three BMIs (22%, 52%, and 88%), with three lesions in each phantom. The lesions were modeled with varying spiculation levels (low, medium, high). A scanner-specific CT simulator (DukeSim), setup to model the NAEOTOM Alpha scanner, was used to simulate imaging of the virtual patients under varying radiation dose (5.7 to 17.1 mGy) and reconstruction parameters (matrix size of 512x512 and 1024x1024, kernels of Bl56, Br56, and Qr56, and slice thicknesses of 0.4 to 3.0 mm). A morphological snakes segmentation method was used to segment the lesions in the reconstructed images. The segmented masks were used to calculate morphological radiomic features across all acquired images. The original phantoms were also run through the same radiomics software to serve as ground truth measurements. The radiomics features were found to be most dependent on slice thickness and least dependent on dose level. By increasing the dose from 5.7 mGy to 17.1 mGy the accuracy in the radiomics measurements increased at most by 2.0%. The Qr56 kernel, 0.34 mm in-plane pixel size and 0.4 mm slice thickness had the more accurate measurements of morphological features (e.g., error of 6.7 ± 5.6 % vs. 11.8 ± 9.6% for mesh volume).
Access to the requested content is limited to institutions that have purchased or subscribe to SPIE eBooks.
You are receiving this notice because your organization may not have SPIE eBooks access.*
*Shibboleth/Open Athens users─please
sign in
to access your institution's subscriptions.
To obtain this item, you may purchase the complete book in print or electronic format on
SPIE.org.
INSTITUTIONAL Select your institution to access the SPIE Digital Library.
PERSONAL Sign in with your SPIE account to access your personal subscriptions or to use specific features such as save to my library, sign up for alerts, save searches, etc.