Tightening requirements on resolution, CD uniformity and positional accuracy push the development of improved
photomask blanks. One such blank for 45nm node attenuated phase shift masks (att-PSM) provides a thinner chrome
film, TF11, with a higher etch rate compared to previous generation NTAR5 att-PSM blanks from the same supplier.
FEP-171, a positive chemically amplified resist, is commonly used in mask manufacturing for both e-beam and DUV
laser pattern generators. TF11 chrome allows the FEP-171 resist thickness to be decreased at least down to 2000 Å while
maintaining sufficient etch resistance, thereby improving photomask CD performance. The lower stress level in TF11
chrome films also reduces the image placement error induced by the material.
In this study, TF11 chrome and FEP-171 resist are evaluated with exposures on a 248 nm DUV laser pattern generator,
the Sigma7500. Patterning is first characterized for resist thicknesses of 2000 Å to 2600 Å in steps of 100 Å, assessing
the minimum feature resolution, CD linearity, isolated-dense CD bias and dose sensitivity. Swing curve analysis shows a
minimum near 2200 Å and a maximum near 2500 Å, corresponding closely to the reflectivity measurements provided by
the blank supplier. The best overall patterning performance is obtained when operating near the swing maximum. The
patterning performance is then studied in more detail with a resist thickness of 2550 Å that corresponds to the reflectivity
maximum. This is compared to the results with 2000 Å resist, a standard thickness for e-beam exposures on TF11. The
lithographic performance on NTAR5 att-PSM blanks with 3200 Å resist is also included for reference. This evaluation
indicates that TF11 blanks with 2550 Å resist provide the best overall mask patterning performance obtained with the
Sigma7500, showing a global CD uniformity below 4 nm (3s) and minimum feature resolution below 100 nm.
Tighter requirements on mask resolution, CD and image positioning accuracy at and beyond the 45 nm technology node
push the development of improved photomask blanks. One such blank for attenuated phase-shift masks (att-PSM)
provides a thinner chrome film, named TF11, with higher chrome etch rate compared to the previous generation Att-
PSM blank (NTAR5 chrome film) from the same supplier. Reduced stress in the chrome film also results in less image
placement error induced by the material. FEP-171 is the positive chemically amplified resist (PCAR) that is most
commonly used in advanced mask manufacturing with both 50 keV variable shaped e-beam (VSB) and DUV laser
pattern generators. TF11 allows an FEP-171 resist film down to about 2000 Å thickness with sufficient etch resistance,
while the standard resist thickness for NTAR5 is around 3000 Å.
This work has experimentally evaluated the use of TF11 chrome and FEP-171 resist together with a 248 nm DUV laser
pattern generator, the Sigma7500. First, patterning performance in resist with thicknesses from 2000 Å to 2600 Å, in
steps of 100 Å, was tested with respect to swing curve and basic lithographic parameters including resolution, CD
linearity, CD iso-dense bias and dose sensitivity. Patterning results on mask showed a swing minimum at around 2200 Å
and a swing maximum at around 2500 Å, which correspond to reflectivity measurements for 248 nm wavelength
performed by the blank supplier. It was concluded that the overall patterning performance was best close to the swing
maximum. Thereafter the patterning performance using TF11 at two resist thicknesses, 2000 Å and 2550 Å, was studied
in more detail and compared to performance using NTAR5 with 3200 Å resist. The evaluation showed that the
Sigma7500-II offers good compatibility with TF11, especially using the optimized FEP-171 resist thickness of 2550 Å. It
also showed that the patterning capability of the Sigma7500-II using TF11 and 2550 Å resist is improved compared to
using NTAR5 and 3200 Å resist.
FEP-171 resist is commonly used both together with 50 keV VSB and DUV laser mask writers. To improve resolution and other lithographic parameters, the industry has strived towards thinner resist and absorber films on the mask blank. The chrome thickness and etch resistance limit how thin the resist can be. The NTAR7 (730Å) chrome was optimized for binary masks for 193 nm lithography, while NTAR5 (590Å) chrome is used for attenuated PSM blanks with a MoSi absorber beneath the chrome film.
Resolution and lithographic performance can be improved further by integrating improved processes, including PEB, development and dry-etch. Micronic has in a series of papers described improvements to the FEP-171 process in combination with different chrome films and the SLM-based DUV (248 nm) Sigma7300 mask writer. The thickness of FEP-171 for Sigma7300 has been optimized for NTAR7 chrome and improvements have been described for the PEB and dry-etch process of the FEP-171/NTAR7 blanks.
In this paper we describe the FEP-171 process development further. We have investigated improvements to the develop process for FEP-171/NTAR7 blanks using Design of Experiments (DOE) and a Steag Hamatech ASP-5000. Improved performance on mask, especially for CD linearity and clear-field/dark-field deviation, was achieved using the resulting development recipe together with the Sigma7300. Better than 5 nm (range) CD linearity in chrome was demonstrated for isolated spaces in the range 200-1400 nm.
This work also covers a process study of FEP-171 on NTAR5 chrome. The resist thickness was optimized to 3200Å for the Sigma7300 and the performance was tested in terms of resolution, resist profile, CD linearity and CD uniformity. Resolution of 120 nm isolated lines and 140 nm isolated spaces was demonstrated, as well as 4 nm (range/2) global CD uniformity.
A continuing improvement in resist process is a necessity for high-end photomask fabrication. In advanced chemically amplified resist systems the lithographic performance is strongly influenced by diffusion of acid and acid quencher (i.e. bases). Beside the resist properties, e.g. size and volatility of the photoacid, the process conditions play important roles for the diffusion control. Understanding and managing these properties influences lithographic characteristics on the photomask such as CD uniformity, CD and pitch linearity, resolution, substrate contamination, clear-dark bias and iso-dense bias. In this paper we have investigated effects on the lithographic characteristics with respect to post exposure bake conditions, when using the chemically amplified resist FEP-171. We used commercially available mask blanks from the Hoya Mask Blank Division with NTAR7 chrome and an optimized resist thickness for the 248 nm laser tool at 3200Å. The photomasks were exposed on the optical DUV (248nm) Sigma7300 pattern generator. Additionally, we investigated the image stability between exposure and post exposure bake. Unlike in wafer fabrication, photomask writing requires several hours, making the resist susceptible to image blur and acid latent image degradation.
Chrome and resist thickness are limiting factors for final resolution on mask. The trend in mask manufacturing is consequently moving towards thinner chrome and resist films.
The Sigma7300 is a 248nm DUV laser pattern generator with optical resolution approaching 100nm. The earlier standard mask blank for the mask writer had 1030Å thick AR8 chrome together with 4000Å FEP-171 resist. To fully benefit from the resolution capability of the mask writer, this study aimed to investigate the 730Å thick NTAR7 chrome together with thinner FEP-171 resist. The dry etch characteristics of thin chrome and thin resist were also studied.
As a first step, a set of plates with varying resist thickness was exposed to extract the swing curve. The resist thickness ranged from 3050Å - 3600Å in steps of 50Å. The fitted curve based on the dose required to break through the resist (dose-to-clear) for different thicknesses showed a maximum at approximately 3200Å. A resolution improvement of about 10nm was achieved in this resist thickness compared to the earlier 4000Å film.
Design of Experiments (DoE) was used to perform a screening of the dry etch process on NTAR7 and the 3200Å resist. All plates were exposed using the Sigma7300. Etching was performed on a UNAXIS Gen III Mask Etcher with standard Cl2/O2/He gas mixture. The dry etch process developed from the DoE responses was used to characterize the lithographic performance on mask from the Sigma7300 together with the new optimized blanks.
CD linearity <10nm (range) was demonstrated both for clear and dark isolated lines down to 180nm line width. Global CD uniformity <6nm (3s) was achieved and very well defined chrome profiles for 150nm isolated clear lines and 130 nm isolated dark lines were demonstrated.
Critical dimension control is becoming more and more critical in the mask making industry as the exposure wavelength goes down. For laser pattern generators, the move from traditional DNQ/Novolak based towards DUV chemically amplified resist processing was initially troublesome. The relative long total exposure time of pattern generators in contrast to wafer steppers, in combination with thick quartz substrates with relatively low heat capacity, may result in
reduced lithographic performance due to excessive diffusion of photogenerated acid. The photoresist polymer architecture play a large role in determining the acid diffusion characteristics and thereby also the image fidelity and resolution. In the Sigma7300 laser pattern generator the image is created by the spatial light modulator, which acts as a reflective computer-controlled reticle. By adopting a proper writing strategy, the negative effects of acid diffusion could be reduced. One component in the Sigma writing strategy is to expose the pattern in several passes that allows for dose compensation as well as averaging schemes to reduce CD errors. By adjusting the dose per pass and by keeping track of the delay times between each shot as well as the exposure path, a better control of the linewidth may be achieved for certain photoresist chemistry. In this study we present results from investigations of AZ DX 1100P and FEP-171 resists using different writing strategies.
For many years, laser pattern generation has been printing on i-line resists. As features sizes continue to shrink, laser pattern generation is moving to DUV laser wavelengths, and a production worthy resist process is needed. Characteristics such as standing waves, resist foot and CD drift under and after exposure have previously challenged efforts to migrate 248nm stepper chemically amplified resists (CARs) to mask making applications. In this study the performance of a commercially available 248nm laser/e-beam resist solution is examined in the Sigma7000 series laser pattern generators. To achieve virtually no resist foot as well as tight CD control the optimum process conditions for DUV laser applications were determined. Cross-sectional and top-down scanning electron microscopy analysis was performed to evaluate the resist and dry etch processes. A comparison is made with the resist DX1100P, used in initial stages for DUV pattern generators development. The new resist also benefits from being well established in mask making e-beam mask writers.
Access to the requested content is limited to institutions that have purchased or subscribe to SPIE eBooks.
You are receiving this notice because your organization may not have SPIE eBooks access.*
*Shibboleth/Open Athens users─please
sign in
to access your institution's subscriptions.
To obtain this item, you may purchase the complete book in print or electronic format on
SPIE.org.
INSTITUTIONAL Select your institution to access the SPIE Digital Library.
PERSONAL Sign in with your SPIE account to access your personal subscriptions or to use specific features such as save to my library, sign up for alerts, save searches, etc.